Yet another way in which America is screwing Iraq
Published by Sabotabby September 22nd, 2007 in A million ways to mortgage the future, Big Business, Environment, Imperialism for Dummies, Politics, War, Yay! Science!So we’ve all heard about the Blackwater thing by now, right? After last Sunday, when Blackwater Christofascist mercenaries went on a killing spree, murdering at least 28 people in cold blood, Iraq’s puppet government finally said “enough is enough,” and revoked Blackwater’s license to operate in the country. This isn’t the first time that Blackwater has done something like this—it’s easy, considering that Blackwater killers are immune from prosecution. They’re only killing Iraqis, after all.
Remember democracy in Iraq, and those teary-eyed American conservatives praising the courage of ordinary men and woman and their purple fingers? Well, turns out that the whole democracy-building adventure was as hollow as we anti-war cynics said it was, because despite the puppet government’s orders, the occupiers have resumed Blackwater convoys. This, despite how deeply horrifying the massacre really was:
Witnesses say the first victims of the shootings were a couple with their child, the mother and infant meeting horrific deaths, their bodies fused together by heat after their car caught fire. The contractors, according to this account, also shot Iraqi soldiers and police and Blackwater then called in an attack helicopter from its private air force which inflicted further casualties.
Pretty par for the course, though, burning parents and babies alive. We’re used to hearing news like that. Here’s a fresh new horror that America is foisting on the long-suffering Iraqi people: Order 81.
Most North Americans, even left-wing, anti-capitalist North Americans, don’t know about the epidemic of debt-related suicides among Indian farmers. You should take some time to learn about it, though—at least 4,500 farmers in central India have killed themselves in the past six years—even higher than the slightly-better-publicized 4,300 Palestinian deaths so far during the Second Intifada. And while neoconservatism has generated righteous anger for its genocidal ideology, the Indian tragedy is a reminder of how brutal neoliberalism has been for the people of the Third World.
So, why are the Indian farmers killing themselves? Because they can’t repay crop loans. Why can’t they repay crop loans? Well, the way farming has worked since the dawn of agriculture is that you have your initial investment, which includes seeds, and you keep reusing your seeds after each harvest. If you don’t have enough, you can trade seeds with your neighbour. But companies like the notorious U.S.-based Monsanto realized that they could make more money manufacturing and pushing genetically modified “terminator seeds,” which are sterile and cannot be reused, forcing farmers into dependence on the company for their livelihood. To make things worse, the genetically modified seeds tend to be hardier than the natural variety, so the sneaky company can just blow some onto an unsuspecting farmer’s field, and presto! The mutant crops overtake the natural crops, and you have a new Monsanto customer-for-life. Nice, huh?
Well, this has worked out so nicely for transnational corporations in India that the Americans have decided to try it in Iraq, because invading, murdering, and looting hasn’t permanently screwed the country enough. When he was administrator of the Coalition Provisional Authority, U.S. diplomat L. Paul Bremer issued a bunch of orders, including the aforementioned Order 81:
What Order 81 did was to establish the strong intellectual property protections on seed and plant products that a company like the St. Louis-based Monsanto — purveyors of genetically modified (GM) seeds and other patented agricultural goods — requires before they’ll set up shop in a new market like the new Iraq. With these new protections, Iraq was open for business. In short, Order 81 was Bremer’s way of telling Monsanto that the same conditions had been created in Iraq that had led to the company’s stunning successes in India.
Dr. Vandana Shiva, a scientist and activist who has done a tremendous amount to fight against the GM assault on India, explains the colonialist dimensions of terminator seeds thusly:
This epidemic of piracy is very much like the epidemic of piracy which was named colonialism 500 years ago. I think we will soon need to name this round of piracy through patents as recolonialization as a new colonialization which differs from the old only in this - the old colonialization only took over land, the new colonialization is taking over life itself.
While the Blackwater mercenaries will eventually be forced to leave, one way or another, terminator seeds are a great way to ensure that Iraq will remain, long into the foreseeable future, a wretched neo-colony of American corporations.
Oh my god, I feel sick. This is disgusting. Is there any bright side to this? I had heard about the farmers’ suicides, but I didn’t know exactly why. This explains so much. I have lost hope for Iraq–and humanity.
In the article about Indian farmers I didn’t see a single mention of a biotech company. The other thing is that if seeds or pollen from a plant that was grown from terminal seeds blow into another field, nothing happens. It could be that companies aren’t doing a good enough job educating the farmers on patent laws, which is the company’s fault and should be fixed. Or maybe company agents are going from field to field during planting, spreading seeds in random fields as part of their nefarious plot.
You also don’t realize that hardly anybody these days collects seeds for use in the next season. Why? Those seeds aren’t worth a damn. They aren’t treated and therefore are at the mercy of whatever white grub, wireworm, rootworm, etc. that wants a snack. Using collected seeds there is no guarantee the seeds from the next generation will be the cultivar you want, in part because most resistance traits are recessive. So if you’ve got a field full of Hybrid A which has been bred for protection against aphids as well as agronomic qualities like taste/color/yield, it could potentially hybridize with the traditional variety that you’ve got planted nearby as a trap crop. And then the F1 generation won’t be what you originally purchased. Maybe F2 will contain 25% of what you originally purchased, assuming everything is Mendel-perfect, which it usually isn’t.
Also, it’s not like scientists develop new cultivars just for kicks. There is a reason this research is done and a reason farmers buy the seeds. The reason being, we’ve got to feed and clothe nearly 7 billion people, and traditional varieties just won’t cut it. People always seem to forget that there is a reason we don’t practice pre-industrial agriculture in industrialized nations. Universities do some of the research, but 80% of agricultural research in the U.S. is done by industry. Not only that, but universities don’t produce seeds in mass quantities to hand out to farmers. I chose my line of work because it’s interesting and I can help a lot of people, but I also need to pay the bills. And I like to get credit for my work. Yes, it’s terrible that corporations are already in Iraq doing their thing. Yes, corporations should give a price break to farmers from developing nations. There are obviously things that could be done to improve the general behavior of companies like Monsanto. But I don’t think they’re evil, I think they’re performing a necessary and ultimately useful service. None of the scientists I know that are in industry are ogres, but maybe that’s not true of the business end of it.
Finally, “natural” is an inaccurate descriptor of traditional varieties. There may still be wild versions of our crop species, but they look nothing like the plants we grow in our fields. Ever since humans began to farm, we’ve been selecting for different traits in our domesticated species. So basically all crops are “mutant” varieties.
Entomologista, you may have pure motives, but the industry as a whole is based around profit, not what’s best for Third World farmers. The Green Revolution was incredibly profitable for agribusiness but increased class disparities in Latin America and, as previously mentioned, has had a tragic effect on India. Industrialized farming also feeds people in the short-term, but could potentially threaten the future food supply because it’s unsustainable.
Obviously, all crops are domesticated, but there’s a difference between “mutant” and “GM.” If GM was so great, corporations wouldn’t be so reticent about labelling their products as such, would they?